Recently, I have been looking into the concept of the backfire effect. That effect plainly states that when people are entrenched in their view, the more information that you provide them to combat their belief, the more they believe in their position.
Here is a video explaining the concept.
Recently, I have been looking into the concept of the backfire effect. That effect plainly states that when people are entrenched in their view, the more information that you provide them to combat their belief, the more they believe in their position.
Here is a video explaining the concept.
Hopefully everyone has seen the holiday classic, Miracle on 34th Street. I thought a quote from the movie might be interesting to consider as it relates to mediation.
Kris Kringle: Oh, Christmas isn’t just a day, it’s a frame of mind… and that’s what’s been changing. That’s why I’m glad I’m here, maybe I can do something about it.
In today’s results oriented society, mediation has often been looked at as effective if it only gets results. However, as Kris notes above, Christmas isn’t just a day, it’s a frame of mind. The same holds true for mediation. Mediation isn’t a day, it is a frame of mind. It is an openness to learning new information and it is a time to be able to try to find a resolution. Many people judge mediation’s success by the outcome at the end. Most of the time, it is a process and the process and journey in mediation are often the most valuable part of the process. The resolution may be a valid outcome, but it doesn’t necessarily mean it is.
Sometimes, mediation is very effective even though it didn’t resolve the case: it can provide perspective; it can provide information; it can provide a place for reflection; and it can be a place to test resolve.
By Steven G. Mehta
Let’s face it. During some negotiations, you may get angry at the other sideyou’re your blood pressure may go up. The problem with that blood pressure is that it is not only bad for your heart, but it is also bad for your ability to negotiate effectively. According to a Clemson University researcher, your ability to recognize emotional cues in is directly linked to your blood pressure.
The study by Clemson University professor James A. McCubbin reveals that people with higher blood pressure are less able to recognize angry, fearful, sad and happy faces and text passages.
“It’s like living in a world of email without smiley faces,” McCubbin said. “We put smiley faces in emails to show when we are just kidding. Otherwise some people may misinterpret our humor and get angry.”
Negotiations are complex situations that involve all types of emotions and issues. It is critical that the negotiators are able to understand the emotional cues that may reveal the other side’s negotiating position. In complex social situations like work settings, people rely on facial expressions and verbal emotional cues to interact with others.
“You may distrust others because you cannot read emotional meaning in their face or their verbal communications,” said McCubbin. ”You may even take more risks because you cannot fully appraise threats in the environment.”
McCubbin refers to this phenomenon as “Emotional Dampening.” In other words, a person has a decreased ability to understand the emotional and social cues of other people.
This research confirms anecdotal research that people do not negotiate as effectively when they are angry. They may make rash decisions and, as this study proves, they may misinterpret critical emotional cues which can change the dynamic of the negotiation.
Take for example, the joint session in mediation. Many times, the parties come into the joint session angry already. They are not ready to listen to the other side. Then they hear something that they don’t want to hear and they become even angrier. Now everything the other person seems hostile. Indeed, there is a saying that we judge other people by their actions, and ourselves by our intentions. Because of the impaired emotional vision, we interpret the other person’s actions negatively. Many times in mediation, this anger-impairment cycle can lead to disastrous consequences.
So if you feel yourself getting hot under the collar because of a negotiation, consider using tactics to calm yourself down first before continuing the negotiations.
McCubbin’s study, published in the journal Psychosomatic Medicine, was supported by the National Heart, Lung and Blood Institute and the National Institute on Aging, both parts of the National Institutes of Health.
The journal article was co-authored by Marcellus M. Merritt of the University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee psychology department; John J. Sollers III if the psychological medicine department at the University of Auckland; Dr. Michele K. Evans of the Laboratory of Immunology, National Institute on Aging; Alan B. Zonderman, Laboratory of Behavioral Neuroscience, National Institute on Aging; Dr. Richard D. Lane of the psychiatry department, University of Arizona; and Julian F. Thayer of the Ohio State University psychology department.
By Steven G. Mehta
Are You a Nibbler?
Now I am not referring to your eating habits. Instead, I am wondering about your negotiation tactics. A nibble is when at the end of the deal, you ask for a little something more. This little something generally doesn’t have huge value in relation to the entire deal. For example, in a car sale, you might be nibbling to get the dealer to throw in the car mats. In litigated cases, many times the negotiator asks the other side to pay certain fees such as filing costs or mediation fees. In an appliance purchase, it might be free delivery. Regardless of the nibble, it is creating a value for you or your client if you get it.
WARNING. Many people just read about the nibble, but don’t pay attention to the warnings that come along with it. The reality is in some negotiations, you may risk destroying the relationship with your negotiating partner. The nibble might turn off the other side who may feel that your tactic is a cheap ploy designed to take advantage of them, done for the sake of trying to be a “WINNER” at the expense of the other side.
Suggestions if you nibble:
Suggestions On How to counter the Nibble:
By Steven G. Mehta
Want to become smarter, even if only for a little bit. Well, I have the answer for you. Chew some gum.
Recently a study found that people who chew gum before testing on a subject increased their cognitive function. The study showed that the increase in brain power, however, lasted only for 15 minutes.
Interestingly, the study also found that the boost in brain power didn’t come from the sugar. People with sugar free gum had the same increase.
O
ne of the reasons that this is interesting for mediation is that many times, little things in mediation can result in big changes. Second, this study demonstrates that by changing the conditions even a little, there is a change in the way people think.
Other ways that you might change the thinking patterns in mediation are:
I have, at some point in time, tried all of these things, and you would be surprised that these little changes can sometimes create a large breakthrough in the mediation.
By Steven G. Mehta
